Welcome to the wild world of game review scores, where “average” films score 2/4 but an “average” game garners 7/10! How does this happen, you ask? Join us as we dive deep into the world of ratings inflation, the differences between professional game reviewers and hobbyists, the curious BoardGameGeek rating system, and of course, the role of hype, personal preference, and selection bias. Unravel the mystery, understand the subjectivity and factors at play, and let’s altogether embark on a thrilling, gaming adventure! Ready, set, play!